Tag Archives: Roads and Road Transport History Association

Diesel drivers face new charges to cut pollution

The Times, Ben Webster, Environment Editor, 29 July 2014

Drivers of diesel cars face penalties and restrictions to combat the growing threat posed by air pollution in cities, The Times has learnt.

Almost all diesel vehicle drivers will have to pay an extra £10 to drive into central London under plans being drawn up by Boris Johnson, the mayor of London. Other cities across the country are looking urgently at ways to cut diesel fumes in order to comply with clean air rules from Europe.

Mr Johnson will also lobby the government to raise road tax on diesel cars to encourage motorists to switch to cleaner vehicles.

Air pollution causes about 29,000 premature deaths a year in Britain and the problem has been worsened by the rapid shift to diesel prompted by government tax incentives designed to lower carbon emissions.

Labour is planning a national network of low emission zones that would force older diesel vehicles out of many cities. Sheffield, Leicester, Bradford, Birmingham, Bristol and 15 other cities with poor air quality are considering introducing low emission zones. Oxford introduced one for buses this year and may extend it to other vehicles.

The £10 charge in the capital would be on top of the congestion charge and would come into play in 2020, meaning that diesel drivers would pay at least £20 to drive into the central London “ultra low emission zone”.

Only those diesels that meet the Euro 6 emissions standard will be exempt. Petrol cars registered before 2006 will also have to pay.

The initiatives are being driven by the threat of heavy fines from the European Commission for breaching air pollution limits. The commission launched legal proceedings against Britain in February.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs admitted that London, Birmingham and Leeds would be exposed to dangerous air pollution from vehicle exhausts until the 2030s unless tougher action were taken. Diesel vehicles produce nitrogen dioxide, which can inflame the lung lining and lead to respiratory disease.

Mr Johnson will launch an “air quality manifesto” today that he claims will take London two thirds of the way to compliance with EU limits. He will say that the government and the commission must deliver the other third.

The government should reverse the incentives for diesel by increasing vehicle excise duty rates and the commission should establish a fund to help cities to switch to electric cars.

Matthew Pencharz, the mayor’s environment adviser, said: “We want to see an unwinding of incentives that have driven people to diesel. Euro engine standards on emissions have not delivered the savings expected, meaning we now have a legacy of a generation of dirty diesels.”

He said the ultra low emission zone, which will have the same boundaries as the congestion charge zone, would encourage drivers of diesel cars to switch back to petrol engines or buy the latest diesel models complying with the new Euro 6 standard. Mr Pencharz dismissed calls by environment groups and some scientists for a ban on most diesel cars in London and said that a £10 charge from 2020 would be fairer.

“It would not be reasonable to say, ‘I’m sorry, you have just bought that car but it’s now banned.’ People bought them in good faith and it’s not fair to clobber them,” he said. “We think a five-year notice gives enough warning. People who drive in once a month might not buy a newer car whereas somebody who drives in every day probably would do.”

Simon Birkett, director of the campaign group Clean Air in London, said that Mr Johnson had previously encouraged dirty diesel cars by exempting smaller ones from the congestion charge.

Smart seatbelts give sleepy drivers a wake-up call

The Times, Oliver Moody, 23 July 2014

Scientists hope to prevent hundreds of road deaths in Britain each year with a seatbelt that wakes motorists up when it senses that they are falling asleep at the wheel.

Devices implanted in the seatbelt and seat cover of a car will keep track of the driver’s breathing and heartbeat to catch signs of tiredness and set off an alarm long before the risk of an accident becomes critical.

In 2013 more than 1,700 people died in road accidents in Britain, and previous studies have estimated that fatigued drivers account for between a fifth and a third of all road deaths in Europe.

The approach of sleep slows people’s reaction times and makes it harder to concentrate, and the number of fatigue-related accidents peaks after lunch between 2pm and 4pm, with another spike in the early hours of the morning.

Truck drivers and shift workers are most likely to nod off at the wheel, and 85 per cent of the motorists who cause crashes through sleep or tiredness are male. Men under 30 are most at risk of fatigue on the roads.

Some car models already keep track of signs that suggest the driver might be falling asleep, including how well they stay in their lanes and how smoothly they accelerate and brake.

The seatbelt project, which is called HARKEN and is led by Spanish and Portuguese engineers, as well as scientists from the University of Manchester, aims to pick up telltale indicators from the driver’s body far in advance of any danger. The heart rate and the frequency of breathing fall as sleep approaches.

Made from “smart” fibres, the devices feed the driver’s vital signs into a dashboard display. The technology has been calibrated to eliminate the “noise” caused by the motion of the car.

The developers claim that the system is “completely unobtrusive” and close to fruition. The seatbelts have been tested on race tracks and are shortly to go on trial on Spanish roads.

José Solaz , of the Institute of Biomechanics in Valencia, said that early tests had yielded “positive and reliable results” and that he expected the devices to appear on the roads in the near future. It is not yet clear how much they will cost.

“The variations in heart and respiratory rate are good indicators of the state of the driver as they are related to fatigue,” he told The Daily Telegraph. “So when people go into a state of fatigue or drowsiness, modifications appear in their breathing and heart rate.

“[The device] can monitor those variables and therefore warn the driver before the symptoms appear.”

A team of scientists from Nottingham Trent University are working on a similar project in which electrocardiograms are embedded into the fabric of car seats, setting off an alert to pull over when the driver shows signs of sleepiness. If the alarm does not wake the motorist up, the system is designed to activate cruise control or other automatic driving technology.

The seat covers will be marketed at lorry drivers and the owners of luxury cars if they prove to be effective.

‘Supermodel’ gets a career boost thanks to some Smart thinking

The Times, Robert Lea, 17 July 2014

The Smart car, the industry-defining Mercedes-Benz micro car whose losses over the years have run into the billions, has for the first time in ten years been given an upgrade.

Last night in Berlin, the global capital of the Smart car, Mercedes revealed a new fuel-efficient ForTwo two-seater and a new version of the ForFour four-seater, a car discontinued in the middle of the last decade.

Taking his cue from the recent Berlin Fashion Week, Dieter Zetsche, the famously politically incorrect head of Mercedes, said of the Smart car: “Like the fashion models they have a small appetite and perfect measurements, and like a supermodel they have long, successful careers.”

In reality, despite defining the future for small city cars as long ago as 1998, the development of the Smart car has stalled for lack of investment.

That has changed with the announcement of a cost-sharing development agreement with Renault-Nissan. The new Smart cars will, like their predecessors, be built in Hambach, on the Franco-German border, but also in Slovenia where Renault is building its city car, the Twingo.

“We were afraid that we would lose ground,” said Dr Zetche of the long wait for a new Smart car. “But we have been selling 100,000 a year, which is an accomplishment given the generation of the product.”

The new Smart cars will come on to the market starting at €10,300 (£9,000), similar to current pricing.

Annette Winkler, chief executive of the Smart brand, said that she envisaged Smart’s competition to be its new stablemate, the Renault Twingo, the Fiat 500 and the Volkswagen Up — and to a certain extent the smaller versions of the Mini.

Dr Zetsche declined to comment on the extent of Smart car losses during the 20 years that Mercedes has been involved in its development and production. “We plainly need to generate value and that is why we are in co-operation with Renault-Nissan, sharing the development costs and the components and to get the scale,” he said.

“We definitely expect to be selling more than 100,000 a year in the future and we now have the foundation for a business case going forward.”

Mercedes will continue to make its current generation of electric Smarts until 2016, but Dr Zetsche said that the company, like many other conventional manufacturers, remain wary of a technology that gives vehicles limited range while investment in charging infrastructure remains in its infancy.

The big wins for the Smart car are the trend toward car-sharing schemes and street-side car hiring projects. “It means the Smart is functional but also cool because it is the way a lot of people, especially a lot of young people, want to drive in cities,” Dr Zetsche said.

Dirty secrets of ‘cleanest yet’ diesel cars

The Times, Ben Webster Environment Editor, 5 August 2014

Pollution from new diesel cars is six times greater than the official limit, according to “real-world driving” emissions tests that contradict results published by manufacturers.

Some of the latest diesel models produce the same amount of nitrogen oxides (NOx) as older ones, which means they could face the same pollution penalties designed to improve air quality in cities.

Boris Johnson, the mayor of London, last week revealed plans to charge owners of existing diesel cars £10 a day to drive into central London from 2020. The latest diesel models, some of which are already in showrooms, are intended to be exempt from the charge because they have to comply with the new Euro 6 standard for pollutants.

However, a study has found that cars that pass the Euro 6 laboratory test routinely produce much higher levels of NOx when driven on roads under more realistic conditions.

NOx and fine particles from diesel engines cause thousands of premature deaths a year in Britain and trigger asthma attacks. The problem has been worsened by the rapid shift to diesel prompted by tax incentives designed to lower carbon emissions.

The Euro 6 limit for NOx is 80 milligrammes per kilometre, less than half the existing limit of 180 mg/km under Euro 5.

Tests commissioned by the Dutch ministry of infrastructure and the environment found that cars that met the official Euro 6 test produced about 500 mg/km during “real-world driving”.

The study, by TNO, a research organisation, found that the gap between the official test and real-world test was greatest on motorways, where it said Euro 6 cars could produce more NOx than Euro 5 ones.

It concludes that a decade of gradual tightening of Euro standards has failed to clean up the NOx in diesel exhausts.

“This experience over the last ten years gives little hope for Euro 6 in the absence of an improved test procedure, or real-driving emission legislation,” the report says.

Richard Smokers, a TNO consultant, said manufacturers were adjusting the engine management systems of their cars to enable them to pass the “very predictable” conditions of the official test conducted in a laboratory.

In real-world driving, with unpredictable braking and acceleration and variations in humidity and air temperature, the lab results could not be replicated.

Dr Smokers said manufacturers were relying on cheap exhaust gas recirculation systems to reduce NOx rather than more expensive but more effective selective catalytic reduction technology (SCR). He said SCR could reduce NOx by 90 per cent but cost £500 per car.

A spokesman for the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders said: “It is widely recognised that there are differences between test results and real-world emissions . . . However, the test is a standardised cycle for comparison purposes that cannot and is not intended to represent the variations of the real world. SMMT accepts the need for a more suitable testing process, and is working closely with manufacturers and regulators to implement a solution.”

Meanwhile, Islington council in London has introduced £20 on-the-spot penalties for drivers who refuse to switch off their engine when parked.

Greg Archer, clean vehicles manager of Transport & Environment, which campaigns to reduce pollution from cars, said: “The continuing high levels of air pollution in cities are largely the result of the way carmakers systematically manipulate tests so that their vehicles perform well in the laboratory but far worse on the roads.

“This means that London may be planning to exempt new diesel vehicles that actually perform no better on the road than older ones.”

Mr Archer said manufacturers were lobbying the European Commission to delay until 2021 the introduction of a compulsory real world emissions test.

Professor Sir Peter Hall

The Times, 5 August 2014

Influential urban planner who shaped London’s Docklands and conceived a transport revolution

The left-leaning town planner Peter Hall and Michael Heseltine, the secretary of state for environment, were unlikely partners as together they surveyed derelict swathes of East London with a vision of their economic transformation at the beginning of the 1980s.

Hall was a slightly scruffy, unconventional figure, who had co-written a book with an anarchist; Heseltine was an impeccably coiffured patrician Conservative minister charged with reinventing Britain’s inner cities after the riots of the early 1980s. The ripples of their seismic decision-making are still being felt in the vast hinterland east of Tower Bridge, where Canary Wharf has grown into a financial powerhouse to rival the City.

Hall’s status as the key government planning adviser of the Thatcher years got off to an inauspicious start. As a member of the South East Economic Planning Council (SEEPC) in the 1970s, he had called for an orbital motorway for London, a new airport at Stansted and an enterprise zone to kickstart development of London’s Docklands. Thatcher abolished the SEEPC in 1979. “As soon as she shut us down she rapidly implemented all three ideas,” said Hall.

As Britain’s most influential postwar planner, Hall was the father of enterprise zones, where property taxes and planning regulations would be relaxed in order to attract investment. He was inspired by the effect of such deregulation in Hong Kong. His big experiment was London Docklands where the concept was wrapped into an urban development corporation with powers to rapidly shape the landscape. There were similar plans for several British cities, although the government backed away amid criticism that the system was anti-democratic.

However, overseas investment came flooding into the Docklands, notably from the Canadian Reichmann brothers whose marque development at One Canada Square, Canary Wharf, catalysed the area’s development into a world-class financial centre. Major banks, such as HSBC, moved into the area’s skyscrapers. The Corporation of London became so alarmed that it reversed its own strict planning constraints and started approving office towers within the Square Mile, such as the “Gherkin”, “the Cheesegrater” and the “Walkie-Talkie”.

When Heseltine returned as secretary of state for environment in John Major’s government in November 1990, he again summoned Hall. The pair came up with a vision for an expanded development along London’s Thames Estuary corridor, which became known as Thames Gateway. The plan was given impetus by the building of the High Speed 1 rail link, from St Pancras.

After Labour returned to power in 1997 Hall became a member of the Urban Task Force led by Richard Rogers which aimed at fostering a vibrant “cappuccino culture” in regenerated inner cities, with some success. Hall was an uncomfortable member alongside people he regarded as “town crammers” and felt that John Prescott had been hijacked by an agenda to increase housing density in city centres. He thought the postwar London plan of Lord Abercrombie, of low density housing with vast green spaces, and which he much admired, was under threat. From early in his career, he had advocated catering for the baby boom with New Towns such as Peterborough and Milton Keynes.

Hall championed long-term planning of big transport infrastructure and found a kindred spirit in the Labour transport minister Andrew Adonis. He influenced the government’s decision to go ahead with the Crossrail tunnel from Liverpool Street to Paddington and he was one of the main cheerleaders of a north-south high-speed rail link. He believed the next big development in London will centre around a major transport interchange at Old Oak Common in west London where HS2 will connect with the Great Western Line and other services. His most cherished idea in recent times was a network of garden cities in the southeast to cater for massive population growth.

As an admirer of the garden city movement, it was apt that Peter Geoffrey Hall was born in Hampstead in 1932. His family moved north and he was educated at Blackpool Grammar School and at St Catherine’s College, Cambridge, where he studied geography and completed a PhD. Hall later became a professor at Reading University and took the chair of planning at the Bartlett, University College London.

He became one of Britain’s most popular authors on cities. In London 2000 (1963) he predicted congestion charging in London. Walking around cities was his hobby. Books, articles and objects collected from these wanderings filled his home in Ealing, before his wife persuaded him to have a cull. He could often be seen, a wiry figure with a shock of white curly hair, jogging around the London suburb. Hall’s knowledge of London’s transport system was encyclopaedic and colleagues travelling with him were amazed at how he knew exactly the right point to get on and off to save precious minutes.

He was married twice, first to Carla Wartenberg in 1962. He married Magdelena Mroz in 1966. She survives him. There were no children from either marriage.

Hall was a genial man with a wry sense of humour. His lectures were so popular that students would sit on steps and spill out into corridors. He remained sprightly in old age, even after treatment for prostate cancer. Hall recently attended a conference in Liverpool and cut his head after falling on a pavement. After waiting in A&E for two hours he could bear it no longer and returned to deliver his speech with a plaster haphazardly covering his cut.

His vision of an offshore airport in the Thames Estuary to replace Heathrow seemed too big a goal even for him, but Boris Johnson has taken it up enthusiastically and it may yet become a posthumous legacy of Hall’s vision.

Professor Sir Peter Hall, town planner and geographer, was born on March 19, 1932. He died on July 30, 2014, aged 82

Self-Publishing Transport Books

Saturday 8th November 2014

A conference being organised by the Trustees of the Michael Sedgwick Memorial Trust (MSMT), entitled ‘How to Self-Publish a Transport-Themed Book’ is being held in the Lecture Theatre of the National Motor Museum’s Collections’ Centre, Beaulieu, on Saturday 8th November 2014.

For those wanting to publish a specialist motoring or transport book it is not easy to find a traditional publisher that will take it on, self-publishing is an interesting alternative. However, for many authors and prospective authors, there is considerable confusion and a lack of understanding about what is involved in self-publishing, and how best to proceed.

The conference will offer a unique opportunity to meet and intermingle with personalities and companies working within the self-publishing worlds and will be an ideal day out for authors thinking about the best way to publish, or already involved in self-publishing, their work.

Whether you are going it alone or using a self-publishing company, this conference will offer an exciting itinerary of interesting lecturers, outlining recent advances in the self-publishing scene and offering ideas for book layouts, sourcing images and financial considerations.

As well as highly qualified session speakers, a number of self-published authors will display their books in the foyer, and will be on hand to discuss their own self-publishing experiences. It is hoped to include those people who have already published with assistance from a service supplier, people who have published on their own without professional assistance, and those who have published with the support of the MSMT.

The day is designed to be informal, providing first-hand experience of self-publishing theory and practice, and encouraging discussion and an exchange of views and experience. Each session will encompass time for questions and discussion. Other features will include:

– Self-publishing providers and their merchandise.
– Hand-outs from the M.S.M.T., marketing services and publishers.
– Facilities open to authors and potential authors of all types of transport literature.
– Examples of book-styles, paper varieties and cover types available.
– Trade stands.

Full details of the conference and booking forms can be found online at www.michaelsedgwicktrust.co.uk.

The chairman for the day will be Graham Robson, well known motoring author, after-dinner speaker and commentator. The cost of the conference is £65 per person, to include tea, coffee and lunch.

Bill Brunell Photographic Collection

The Motoring Picture Library has just added 5,000 images from the National Motor Museum Trust’s Bill Brunell Photographic Collection to its website www.motoringpicturelibrary.com, a valuable addition which will be of great interest to the motoring enthusiast and professional researcher alike.

A professional photographer, Bill frequently competed in rallies and trials, most famously partnering the Hon. Victor Bruce in 1926 when they became the first Englishmen to win the Monte Carlo Rally. His daughter, Kitty, who features in many of the photographs, also took part in many motoring events including the Monte Carlo Rally of 1929, driving the Talbot 14/45 that she had designed the body for and which became known as the Sportsman’s Coupe. Talbot was so impressed, both with her driving and design skills that it built another car for her for 1930, known as ‘Kitty II’.

Motoring Picture Library Manager, Jon Day said: “Brunell’s photography, shot mainly on glass plate in the 1920s and 1930s, is an evocative reminder of the golden age of British motoring, capturing perfectly the mood and spirit of the era. From street and social scenes to events, trials and rallies throughout Great Britain and Europe, Brunell’s images are an important historical record with artistic merit in their own right.

Buses Festival 2014

Buses Festival 2014 is an exciting new event that will thrill all bus and coach enthusiasts and the public at large.

On Sunday, 31 August, at the Heritage Motor Centre, up to 100 restored Buses and Coaches will be on display, plus modern PSVs and industry suppliers will be in attendance.

There will be heritage bus rides over local routes and the Heritage Motor Centre’s internal road network.

Watch this space for the latest news about attractions, exhibitors and traders.

The centre itself offers excellent entertainment in its own right and entry to the museum is included in the entry price. With over 180 vehicles on display showcasing British innovations in both road and race cars it has a lot to offer. In addition, it has first class catering facilities, toilets including disabled facilities, a gift shop and ample free parking.

Advance tickets are now available, so book early to enjoy cheaper entry to what will truly be one of the best classic and modern bus and coach events of the year.

Please note: Buses are added to the vehicles attending list when the organisers receive written confirmation from an operator or owner that they plan to attend. However, the appearance by any bus or coach cannot be guaranteed due to serviceability, operational commitments or other reasons outside the control of the Event Organisers.

 

Bids to take over Victorian tram shed in Cardiff

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-28440730, 31 July 2014

Tramsheds The building has been up for sale for 18 months

Historic tram and trolley bus sheds could become a new cultural centre for the Welsh capital.

The Grade II listed buildings in the Grangetown area of Cardiff were put on the market 18 months ago.

The council has confirmed its received offers for the Victorian buildings, and is looking for a “viable and sustainable solution” for the site.

Local politicians say arts and culture must play a part in any new development.

A deadline for interest parties has now ended and the council has confirmed bids have been received.

A spokesman said the council was now looking to “see the building fully refurbished in line with its listed status, including potential community uses”.

It is understood one of the bids involves a mix of business and living space.

The building at Pendyris Street, which is on the edge of Grangetown, is across the river from a new enterprise zone which is seen as key to the city centre’s regeneration.

Artist impression of how the sheds might be developed Artist impression of how the sheds might be developed
Inside the tram sheds The building was a venue for three exhibitions as part of the Diffusion festival

Conditions of the sale for business use have been to include a community room, with hopes also of potentially developing arts and dance studios, an auditorium or cinema, alongside small businesses and work units.

The building was formerly earmarked as a contemporary art gallery as part of the city’s failed European City of Culture bid more than a decade ago.

Over the last year, pop-up photographic exhibitions have been held as part of a city-wide festival, as well as a dance and animation event to showcase the building’s potential.

The depot was used to house trams, which ran in the area from the early 1880s, and then trolley buses until they stopped running 60 years ago.

The building had been used for repairing council vehicles over recent years but its redbrick facade with arches is listed.

David Drake, director of Ffotogallery – which is looking for a new Cardiff home – has met with universities, arts organisations and innovations group Nesta, about a partnership to develop the building.

He said it was good news a credible developer had come forward and he was keen to speak to them once negotiations with the council were complete.

“We think it’s a fantastic space and we’d love to do something again there with the Diffusion festival next year,” he said.

“With the BBC’s plans for the front of the station, that whole area will be changing in character and it would bring the Tramsheds back towards what’s going on in the city centre.

“It’s also a very interesting building with a lively residential community in Grangetown and Riverside nearby and it would be fantastic to develop community and cultural provision for that area.”

Local councillor Ashley Govier said he was encouraged there had been interest.

“I still want to see a cultural centre, similar to what you see at Chapter but reflecting the different cultures in this area.”

Related Stories

Dundee bus driver shamed on TV unfairly dismissed

The Courier, 28 July 2014. Contributed by Philip Kirk, who knows about these things – “I don’t know who has more to learn from all of this: the company, the driver or the omnibologist!”

A Dundee bus driver whose rude gesture at a bus spotter was seen on BBC’s Have I Got News For You was unfairly dismissed.

An employment tribunal has ruled that National Express Dundee was wrong to sack Scott McDonald for raising his middle finger at the enthusiast who was photographing his vehicle.

The incident should have been treated as a “one off” and although the driver’s behaviour was stupid he should not have been sacked.

Mr McDonald, 29, was driving one of the company’s new hybrid buses in Commercial Street in August last year when the omnibologist took the picture. The driver gave him the “bird” sign by raising his middle finger.

The spotter reported the episode to the company, whose acting assistant operations manager Philip Bowen called Mr McDonald to a “fact-finding” meeting.

Mr McDonald said he had made the gesture because he didn’t like his photograph being taken by strangers. He admitted his conduct was not befitting that of a professional PCV driver and he had tarnished the company’s image.

He said he would not repeat the incident. Mr Bowen told him he was being suspended on full pay and that the matter was being referred to the disciplinary procedure.

At a meeting on August 23, Mr McDonald said he was suffering from issues outside work, had been feeling edgy and the incident was a stupid mistake.

With the company’s assistance he had attended a counselling session but felt he needed more.

He apologised for the incident, was remorseful and pledged there would be no repeat, and said he would apologise to the complainant if necessary.

Mr Bowen decided to escalate the case to a level where it would be considered by a manager with the authority to dismiss.

He was later told by a friend the photograph had appeared on the BBC’s satirical quiz show featuring Ian Hislop and Paul Merton.

At the higher level hearing on August 29 conducted by Paul Clark, then operations manager, Mr McDonald referred to his personal issues and said he was “pushed over the edge”.

Unite branch chairman Robert McKelvie, who accompanied Mr McDonald, referred to a similar case in which a driver who had given a passenger a V-sign was sacked but later reinstated after an appeal.

Mr Clark adjourned the meeting to check McDonald’s employment file and learned that he had not attended further counselling, although there was a doubt about him having received a letter about such sessions.

He reconvened the meeting and said Mr McDonald had brought the company into disrepute and was being dismissed. Mr McDonald appealed on grounds of excessive severity but managing director Phil Smith ruled that the dismissal would stand.

Tribunal judge Ian McFatridge said Mr McDonald’s behaviour had been unacceptable but the company’s disciplinary policy did not specify that making hand signals at drivers or pedestrians would be viewed as serious or gross misconduct leading to dismissal.

Mr Smith was incorrect when he stated Mr McDonald’s gesture could be categorised as “violence towards another person during the course of their duties or while attending work”.

Mr McFatridge said the fact that Mr Smith had given evidence to this effect indicated “he had to some extent lost any sense of proportion over the incident”.

The gesture was unacceptable and stupid but not at the most serious end of the spectrum.

Mr McDonald should have been subject to some disciplinary penalty but dismissal was outwith the band of reasonable responses.

Mr McDonald has since gained another job and the tribunal ruled that his compensation should be reduced to £5,516.47 because of his contributory actions.

He said at the weekend: “I am happy that I won my case and that I’ve got back everything I lost in the last year.”

A spokeswoman for National Express Dundee said the company were aware of the judgment.

http://www.thecourier.co.uk/news/local/dundee/have-i-got-news-for-you-dundee-bus-driver-shamed-on-tv-unfairly-dismissed-1.494366